I think some of that is due in part to the old guard agreeing that that latest offerings aren't holding a candle to the old stuff. When the site started, things like Scar, Stretchline, New Zeros, were all brand new, so the 'old days' were classic Zeros and Jackets. Now we have a few eras where Oakley shined in each person's mind. I see the Splice and Eye Jacket 3 being called vintage, and feel really old.
But I'm glad the site doesn't have to moderation heavy. Even for legit reasons. I don't even know who the mods are anymore as there hasn't been a need in years.