They don't seem to be very popular around these parts, but I like the new icon. It's very different and I love the novelty of it. Oakley has been putting a lot of big icons on some of their new releases, which makes sense since they've been sponsoring a lot of stars lately and want their logo to be visible in all forms of media. But to me, large icons just look tacky. The new icons, even though it's still very large, is a littel more nondescript (as much as it can be, anyway) than its predecessor.
As for the Silver Text pair specifically, yes, I think chrome icons would ruin it (but I thought it came with matte black icons?). Something darker would work better, IMO.