Frame- Stainles Face-Copper This first edition Judge in polished stainles is leaps and bounds cooler than the Judge 2. Love It!

Just arrived in the mail - picked up on eBay for $147, absolutely love it.

Frame: Stainless Steel Honed/Black Leather
Face: Black/White

Snagged this one for over half off at the Vault. Great classic styling with the honed metal on black leather. The dial and hands are way more "Oakley" than on the Judge models that followed. Any watch can have straight arrow looking hands; this one has little blades and second hand that looks like a Halo weapon. The white face with the black trim are an excellent contrast and the face looks and is really big. The date is very easy read at a distance. My one and only beef is in the Strap; it has two loops for affixing, one of which is right next to the buckle and it makes it hard to initially slide the strap through after closing the buckle. Otherwise, a fine time piece.

I was able to pick up the Honed/Black and White Leather of SAC for $190. First off, this watch is beautiful. I have two minor complaints, though. First, the band seems a bit small for a decent-sized person. Second, the chronograph doesn't seem to keep accurate time. Even though the instructions indicate that each 360 degree rotation of the minute hand of the small dial is 30 minutes, and the hour hand is one hour, each rotation is uneven, and the hour hand counts 30 minute intervals. The last bit is that the second hand on the main dial only works in chronograph mode. I'd be willing to give up the chronograph to make the second hand work normally. So, my dilemma is that I either put up with the chronograph being no right, or I deal with the second hand never counting seconds. I guess I'm OCD when it comes to watches.

stealth-stealth
This time piece feels luxurious on your wrist and draws many compliments each day. I simply love this watch. I have worn it religiously for nearly a year now. It does show signs of wear on the band and I plan to replace in the near future and wear it a little less often...GREAT WATCH.

Frame: Polished
Face: Copper

A classy and blinging watch with a nice weight that reassures you both of its style and its price. The watch was bought as a graduation present (to myself) and I find it hard not to look at it all the time. Is this watch worth it? Definitely. Would recommend also the Large Soft Watch Vault as it fits perfectly should the need arise to take this watch off (God knows why)

I got this watch as a wedding present from my wife. An awesome present and I loved it and got tons of compliments. The stealth black coating completely wore off the band where my wrist rested on the table in less than 3 months and the clasp wouldn't stay closed. But I still loved it. Then about a month later, I found it on the floor next to my coffee table which is about two feet high. The face was completely cracked and spiderwebbed underneath. This is supposedly impossible to break sapphire crystal. I called Oakley and sent it in for repair - five weeks later and MANY phone calls telling me this was normal wear not covered by warranty I paid $150 to get it back. The clasp and face were repaired and I was happy again. However, three weeks or so later another chip in the face appeared out of nowhere. Refusing to pay another 150 I wear it as is. It looks awesome if you don't notice the chip. If you want an awesome looking watch that apparently needs to be wrapped in padding if worn outside of a soft cotton room, this is what you want. But being a doctor and not a construction worker normal wear was obviously WAY TOO much for this watch. Also, Oakley was VERY uncooperative with repairs and I think there is a defect in the crystals they use. Still I am an Oakley fan and recommend their products but they need to stand behind the durability of their product - especially when it costs $650.

Frame: Polished
Face: Copper

This watch may be pricey but it is worth every penny. Just look at it in person. I have had this watch for a while. The frame can get scuffed but is not too noticeable due to the polished characteristic. I found and peers agree that the watch works in both a casual and professional attire. I have not had a problem with performance. The watch is heavier than any watch I own but it is not a problem it adds to its robustness. I am tempted to get the stealth version of this watch. It is that good.

Frame: Stainless Steel Honed
Face: Blue

Hopefully people wont judge, if you exscuse the pun, the blue faced judge from the stock image on O.com as it is way better looking than that. Lighter than the blue dials used on the icon and TB it's more like the electric blue used on the detonator. Wisely Oakley decided to go with the honed casing rather than the polished SS as i'm not sure it would have looked right. For me this combo has displaced the copper as the judge to have.

Frame: Stainless Steel Honed
Face:Black and White leather

The Oakley Judge design re-defined for a far more conservative look. Black leather strap compliments the black face perfectly, 5mm thick leather strap stitched with white cotton augmentation , sturdy and solid. Fixed and held in place by 2 steel screws either side of the crown. Date window as per the original Judges. Again another really nice addition to the Judge collection

Frame: Stainless Steel Polished
Face:Brown and White leather

Understated though every bit the Oakley Judge design. Brown leather strap compliments the brown face perfectly, 5mm thick leather strap stitched with white cotton augmentation , sturdy and solid. Fixed and held in place by 2 steel screws. Date window as per the original Judges. Overall a really nice addition to the Judge collection

Frame: Polished
Face: Copper

Really a nice watch. Got mine for a great price and I'm loving it every day. It's my first Oakley analog watch and hopefully just one of many too come. Pretty comfortable although it is a bit heavy.

This is a beautifull watch. It is as pointed out very heavy though and because my wrist size falls just between 2 adjustments of the wristband so it's constantly slipping down. I dont mind that really. I was somewhat more disappointed to see "S Steel china bracelet" printed on the wristband. I thought Oakley was all made in USA. I would also liked to have seen an alarm function. Lastely: with a watch this imposing it would have been nice to have a real leather case instead of vinyl but maybe that is too much to ask.

Band: Polished
Face: Copper

I obtained this beauty from Josh. I would give it 5 stars except for its weight. Its the first Oakley watch I've worn that draws equal compliments from Men and Women. I don't think its too loud or flashy, and I'm an aggressive sort so I wear it almost everyday.

K

Frame: Polished
Face: Copper
Wow, this is a beauty, unique color combo. This watch is heavy, Although I haven't weighed the watch, It feels slightly lighter than my Blade.
If you like loud. this is for you. Thew only comment I'd have on the negative side is... You can buy a replacement Black Leather band for the Honed Judge, but for the Copper, the only choice you have is a brown leather band, to match the chrome. Not really nice. Otherwise, if you want to wear as is....this is the one to get

Beautiful Watch love to wear it as much as my time bomb only problem is this thing is heavy and after wearing a time bomb daily for a year it kinda takes some time to get used to the weight of this watch. The second hand also kind threw me off as it does not move ( so i thought the watch was defective) unless you press the top button and it is in what i guess would be "chronograph" mode

Frame: Polished
Face: Copper

The must have Judge for me, as other colourways look too similar to the GMT. Though the body is slightly deeper than the GMT.Same sapphire crystal as the GMT so very hardwearing.
Would have liked to have seen the brown / leather band version
Awesome design and just gorgeous.

Frame: Polished
Face: Copper

what can i say? the Polished/Copper Judge is awesome! it's quite weighty, feels like a solidly built piece of equipment. the Judge is beautifully designed, and it's definitely an eye catcher. it looks aggressive, even slightly intimidating, so it's definitely not an everyday watch. but still, when you wear it, everyone will take notice.

The quality is unsurpassed. Already having a GMT i was unsure if I should get something so similar. Finally commited and was blown away buy the Watch in the Flesh. Possibly the most beautiful watch Oakley makes...Highly Recommended. As for the weight my wrist feels naked without it now!

again a nice heavy timepiece love the copper face the best

Frame: Polished
Face: Copper

This watch has a style all its own. People see it and have to comment on it. It's a bit imposing really. It's the kind of watch that makes you feel like everyone is checking you out. I love the bracelet and clasp - very cool. Personally, the copper dial has the most "bang".

Frame: Polished
Face: Copper

A superb watch. I love the face design and the copper color. The date is much easier to read compared to all other analog watches. My only gripe is that the band is the same as my GMT, which has made justification to get the Judge difficult to make.

Frame: Any
Face: Any
An imposing looking time machine. Would like one, but I'd probably opt for the Blade or GMT first. Still, an awesome looking watch.

Frame: Polished
Face: Cooper
Unique but way too expensive just for Time and stop watch. I like it better than the GMT. the shape is almost the same. I would give this a 5 because of it's classy look

Frame: polished
Face: copper

awesome watch, get alot of compliments for it, i used to wear a tissot but switched over, the polish is so shiny!
unique watch, i like how heavy it is, i feel naked without it now,
would be cool if it had some more functions tho,
and i dont like that the band says china bracelet, but the quality is good and u'll get attention for it,