Charcoal/Black
Wow, I'm first.
I really like these -- they're light and comfortable and they look nice for casual wear. I'm replacing my old ratty pair of sneakers with them, and these look a lot nicer. They're awesome for driving, too.
My one complaint is that they look a little funny to the wearer. From the right side or the left side they look fine, but from above (wearer's point of view) the leather (charcoal on mine) looks lopsided on the toe. That's a minor complaint though, and only matters to the wearer.